Peyronie’s surgery: plication vs grafting vs implant

Penile straightening surgery for Peyronie’s disease means one of three operations. This guide compares them on length, erections, hourglass deformity, recovery and risk, so you can see which fits your curve.

When Peyronie’s disease has settled but the curve still stops you having sex, penile straightening surgery is the most reliable way to correct it. There are three operations: plication, which shortens the longer side; plaque incision or excision with grafting, which releases the scar and patches the gap; and a penile implant, with extra straightening at the same operation if it is needed. Each one gains something and gives something up.

Three things decide which is right for you, roughly in this order: the quality of your erections, the size and shape of the curve (including any hourglass narrowing), and your length. The table compares the operations using the figures in the BAUS patient leaflet and on my own pages. The sections below explain the trade-offs.

Plication, plaque incision and grafting, and penile implant compared for Peyronie’s disease
PlicationPlaque incision and graftImplant ± straightening
Best suited toCurves under about 60°, good erections, adequate lengthSevere curves, hourglass or complex shapes, good erectionsAny curve with erections that tablets do not fix
ShorteningAlmost all menAbout 1 in 5 (20%)Does not restore length already lost
Erectile dysfunction afterwardsAbout 1 in 20 (5%)About 1 in 4 (25%)The implant provides the erection
NumbnessAbout 1 in 20 (5%)About 1 in 4 (25%)The implant itself does not alter sensation or orgasm
Hourglass narrowingNot suitableYesStraightening can be added
Hospital stayDay case or one nightDay case or one nightUsually one night

Which Peyronie’s operation is right for my curve?

Erections come first. Good erections with a moderate curve usually means plication; good erections with a severe curve or hourglass deformity usually means grafting; poor erections usually means an implant.

Erections come first because a man who cannot keep a rigid erection will not be well served by straightening alone, and because grafting is only a sensible choice if erections are good beforehand. That is why I measure erectile function rather than estimate it, using a penile Doppler ultrasound where needed.

The curve comes next. BAUS describes plication as generally best suited to bends of less than 60°, and grafting to more severe bends. Treat 60° as a guide rather than a rule: the European Association of Urology (EAU) guideline notes that this threshold for severe curvature has been proposed but not validated. Shape matters as much as angle. The EAU considers plication appropriate for men with good erections, adequate length, a non-severe curve and no complex deformity such as an hourglass or hinge.

Length comes last, but it matters to almost everyone. The EAU says tunical lengthening surgery (grafting) is preferable where there is significant shortening, a severe curve or a complex deformity, but no underlying erectile dysfunction. Beyond these factors, the decision depends on what matters most to you: length, straightness or the reliability of your erections.

No operation returns the penis to how it was

BAUS is explicit that no penile straightening procedure can return the penis to its normal, pre-curvature state, and the NHS says the same. The realistic aim is a penis that is functionally straight for comfortable, satisfying sex. Peyronie’s disease has usually caused some shortening already, so compare each option with your penis as it is now, not as it was before the disease began.

How does penile plication work?

Plication places stitches on the longer side of the penis, opposite the plaque, so that both sides match and the penis straightens. It does not disturb the erectile tissue.

It is reliable and technically straightforward, and it carries a low risk of erectile dysfunction or numbness: BAUS puts each at about 1 in 20 (5%). The EAU reports that complete straightening is achieved in more than 85% of men with these shortening techniques, and that recurrence of the curve and reduced sensation are uncommon (around 10%).

The trade-off is length. BAUS says plication always causes a degree of shortening, closely linked to the amount of “bunching” needed to correct the curve, so the bigger the bend, the more length is used up. Nesbit’s procedure is one well-known plication technique. Plication is also the usual operation for a curve present from birth; my guide to congenital curvature and Peyronie’s disease explains the difference.

What is plaque incision and grafting?

The scar plaque is cut or partly removed to release the tethering, and the gap in the sheath is patched with a graft. It lengthens the short side instead of shortening the long side.

This preserves length much better and can correct severe curves, hourglass deformity and complex bends in more than one direction that plication cannot. BAUS puts shortening after grafting at about 1 in 5 (20%). The Lue procedure used vein grafts originally, but BAUS notes that most urologists now use pre-packaged grafts.

The cost is a higher risk to erections and sensation, because the surgery is done directly over the erectile tissue and the nerves have to be lifted out of the way. BAUS gives a risk of about 1 in 4 (25%) for each. The EAU also notes that lengthening procedures rarely produce a lasting gain in length; their aim is to limit the shortening that plication would cause. Because grafting needs good erections beforehand, the EAU notes that Doppler ultrasound may be used to check arterial inflow before it.

When is a penile implant for Peyronie’s disease the best option?

When you have Peyronie’s disease and erection problems that tablets have not fixed. An implant treats both at once, and on its own it often straightens the penis.

BAUS states that for men with any degree of curvature whose erections have not responded to tablets such as sildenafil or tadalafil, an implant may be the best surgical option, and that implanting the prosthesis alone is usually enough to straighten the penis. The EAU makes a strong recommendation for implantation, with or without additional straightening, in men with Peyronie’s disease and erectile dysfunction that does not respond to medication. If the bend left after the implant is placed is under 30°, the EAU advises no further action; where more correction is needed, modelling, plication or grafting can be added during the same operation.

Two points need careful counselling. The decision is irreversible: if an implant is ever removed, natural erections do not return. And the EAU notes that satisfaction after implant surgery is significantly lower in men with Peyronie’s disease than in the general population, and that men must be told the implant is not designed to restore their previous length. My page on penile implant surgery covers the operation itself, and my guide to penile implant questions covers lifespan, size and cost.

Can surgery correct an hourglass deformity?

Yes, but not usually with plication. Hourglass narrowing, indentation and hinge deformities are generally corrected with a graft, or with straightening during implant surgery if erections are poor.

An hourglass deformity is a waist-like narrowing of the shaft, and some men also have a hinge effect, where the penis bends at that point. The EAU guideline excludes complex deformities such as an hourglass or hinge from the group for whom plication is appropriate, and prefers lengthening (grafting) surgery for them in men without erectile dysfunction. It also describes extra-tunical grafting for hourglass deformity, where a graft is placed over the outside of the sheath, with a lower reported risk of erectile dysfunction (0–2.9%) than standard grafting and satisfaction rates of up to 85.7–100%. The shape of the deformity is one of the things I measure before recommending an operation, along with the angle of the curve and your length.

Does Peyronie’s surgery make your penis shorter?

Plication always shortens the penis to some degree, grafting usually causes less shortening, and an implant does not restore length already lost to the disease.

BAUS lists shortening after plication as affecting almost all patients. The EAU reports shortening of 1–1.5 cm in 22–69% of men after shortening techniques, adds that this rarely causes sexual problems afterwards, and notes that men may perceive the loss as greater than it is. After grafting, BAUS puts shortening at about 1 in 5. For implants, the BAUS counselling checklist is blunt: an implant will not provide extra length and will not restore length lost through Peyronie’s disease.

I measure you and give you realistic numbers rather than reassurance. If length is your main worry, it is worth knowing that traction or vacuum therapy may help preserve the length you have; my guide to non-surgical Peyronie’s treatment explains what that commitment involves.

What are the side effects of Peyronie’s disease surgery?

The main ones are erectile dysfunction, numbness, shortening and recurrence, and how likely each is depends on the operation. Bleeding, infection and palpable stitches can follow any of them.

  • Erectile dysfunction — uncommon after plication and a genuine risk after grafting. BAUS gives about 1 in 4 after grafting; the EAU warns men who have no erection problems before surgery that the risk can be as high as 50%. The figures differ because the studies differ, but they point the same way.
  • Altered or reduced sensation — about 1 in 20 after plication and about 1 in 4 after grafting (BAUS).
  • Circumcision — BAUS says about 1 in 4 men need a circumcision as part of either operation.
  • Residual or recurrent curvature — BAUS says almost all men are left with a residual bend of less than 20°, which should still give a functionally straight penis. A later recurrence after plication affects between 1 in 10 and 1 in 50.
  • Bleeding, haematoma, infection and palpable suture knots, which can follow any of these operations.

An implant has its own risks, chiefly infection, which is uncommon but serious and usually means removing the device, and mechanical failure over time, which can be repaired.

What is the success rate of Peyronie’s disease surgery?

For straightening, it is high: the EAU reports complete straightening in more than 85% of men after shortening operations such as plication. The bigger differences between the operations are in length, erections and sensation afterwards.

There is no head-to-head answer to which operation is best. The EAU notes that there have been no randomised trials comparing surgical outcomes in Peyronie’s disease, so the choice rests on matching the operation to your curve, your length and your erections rather than on a league table. Recurrence of the curve is uncommon when surgery is done once the disease is stable, which is why the timing of the operation matters so much.

Why must Peyronie’s disease be stable before surgery?

Because a curve that is still changing can keep changing after the operation. I consider surgery once the disease has been stable for at least three to six months, with no change in the curve and no pain.

In practice, that usually means at least twelve months from when symptoms started. Published guidance varies on the exact window. The EAU accepts resolution of pain and a curve that has been stable for at least three months; BAUS says the stable phase is usually reached at least six months after the pain has stopped; and one NHS trust page, last updated in 2021, describes a period of observation of at least 12 months. The EAU makes a strong recommendation to operate only when the disease is stable and the deformity is getting in the way of sex. Dated photographs of a natural erection, taken every few months, are the simplest way to show that your curve has stopped changing.

How long does Peyronie’s disease surgery take?

BAUS gives one to two hours for plication and up to about three hours for plaque incision and grafting. Most men go home the same day or after one night.

Straightening surgery is done under general anaesthetic, usually as a day case or with one night in hospital. Implant surgery is done under general or spinal anaesthetic, most men stay one night, and a catheter is used overnight in many cases.

What is the recovery time after Peyronie’s surgery?

Most men are back at desk work within one to two weeks and resume sex at around six weeks. Heavy lifting and strenuous exercise are avoided for around four to six weeks.

Expect swelling and bruising for two to four weeks, and a dressing for the first few days. Where a graft has been used, I may advise a vacuum device or traction during recovery to maintain length and prevent the graft contracting. After an implant, the device is left deflated at first, and I show you how to use it at a follow-up appointment, usually around three to four weeks after surgery. Using the pump takes a little practice.

How much does Peyronie’s disease surgery cost in the UK?

I do not publish fixed surgical prices, because the cost depends on which operation you need and where it is done. You receive a written quotation after your consultation.

The main things that drive the cost are the surgeon’s and anaesthetist’s fees, the hospital fee, whether you go home the same day or stay overnight, the graft material or implant device, and follow-up care. If you are insured, check with your insurer before booking whether the operation is covered and what authorisation they need. An initial consultation is £350 in person or £300 by video or telephone, and a follow-up is £250. My fees and insurance page has the detail, and my page on straightening procedures describes the operations I offer. For background on the condition itself, see my Peyronie’s disease page, or contact my team to arrange an assessment.

Sources and further reading

  1. BAUS: Penile straightening for erectile deformity (patient leaflet A24/087, published Oct 2024)
  2. BAUS: Peyronie's disease (patient leaflet A25/088, published Mar 2025)
  3. EAU Guidelines on Sexual and Reproductive Health: Penile Curvature (2026 edition)
  4. BAUS: Implantation of penile prostheses, patient counselling (A23/190)
  5. NHS trust: Penile straightening (Nesbit or Lue operation), page last updated Feb 2021
  6. NHS: Peyronie's disease (reviewed 3 Jun 2024)
Questions

Frequently asked

What are the Nesbit and Lue procedures?

They are names you will see for the two main straightening operations. BAUS uses Nesbit’s procedure as its example of plication, which straightens the penis by shortening the longer side. The Lue procedure is its example of plaque incision and grafting, which releases the plaque and patches the gap. The Lue procedure originally used a vein graft, but most urologists now use pre-packaged grafts.

Will I need to be circumcised?

Possibly. BAUS reports that about 1 in 4 men need a circumcision as part of either plication or grafting. It is something I discuss with you before surgery, so it is not a surprise on the day. If you are already circumcised, the question does not arise.

Will I feel the stitches after plication?

Some men can. Palpable suture knots under the skin are a recognised risk of plication, because the operation works by placing stitches on the longer side of the penis. If this would bother you, say so beforehand, because it is part of weighing plication against grafting.

Is there an operation that adds length?

Not reliably. The EAU notes that grafting rarely produces a lasting gain in length; its aim is to limit shortening. Implants are not designed to restore lost length. The EAU also makes a strong recommendation against the “sliding” technique, because of a significant risk of life-changing complications such as glans necrosis. Be cautious of any operation sold on the promise of extra length.

Do I need a Doppler scan before Peyronie’s surgery?

If your erections need measuring, yes. Penile duplex ultrasound is used where erectile function needs objective measurement, because it materially changes which operation is appropriate. The EAU notes that Doppler ultrasound may be used to check arterial inflow before plaque incision and grafting, to exclude arterial erectile dysfunction, so that men with poor blood flow are steered towards an operation that suits them.

Will I need traction or a vacuum device after surgery?

Sometimes. Where a graft has been used, I may advise a vacuum device or traction during recovery to maintain length and prevent the graft contracting. If it is recommended for you, I explain how often to use the device and for how long, because consistent use is what makes it worthwhile.

Is Peyronie’s surgery available on the NHS?

Availability varies between NHS areas, and your GP can advise on the local funding policy and referral route. If you choose to be seen privately, the initial consultation is £350 in person or £300 by video or telephone. If surgery is recommended, you receive a written quotation before deciding anything.

Speak to my team

Appointments at The Shard and Canary Wharf are arranged by my PA, Jeanette Bush. Tell us briefly what the problem is and we will find the right clinic slot for you.

Call Request appointment